Shoppers for empathy are tuning in as Colton Underwood says he sought out married men before coming out, a confession that highlights how fear, image and religion can shape risky choices , and why those choices matter for wider conversations about closeted people and accountability.

Essential Takeaways

  • Public confession: Colton Underwood told a podcast he pursued sexual encounters with married men while closeted, saying he thought they had “more to lose.”
  • Motivation: He framed the behaviour as fear-driven, aimed at keeping his sexuality hidden during a time when his TV persona emphasised virginity.
  • Background pressure: Raised in a religious setting and chasing a sports career, Underwood tried to convince himself he could change his attractions.
  • Aftermath: Underwood came out in 2021, made a Netflix series about his journey, is now married and a parent, and reflects that the choices were “messed up” but born of self-protection.
  • Broader concern: The revelation raises questions about secrecy, power imbalances, potential harm to others, and how closeted cultures can push people into risky patterns.

Why this matters: fame, fear and the closet’s dangerous logic

Colton Underwood’s admission lands with a physical twinge , there’s something quietly unsettling about someone choosing partners because they seem least likely to expose them. The former Bachelor lead told the We Need to Talk podcast he thought married men had “more to lose,” and that calculation shaped his decisions. According to outlets reporting the interview, he now calls that mindset “messed up,” but he also insists it came from fear and the need to protect himself. Readers should note that this isn’t just celebrity gossip; it’s a glimpse into how closeting can distort judgement and push people into ethically fraught territory.

The backstory: image, religion and the “Virgin Bachelor” label

Underwood rose to prominence in 2019 with a packaged persona , the so-called Virgin Bachelor , and that narrative obscured a private scramble to reconcile faith, sport and desire. He’s spoken previously about growing up religious and attempting to make himself straight by pursuing relationships with women, as outlets have documented. When your public identity hinges on a tidy story, there’s pressure to keep anything that doesn’t fit hidden, and that pressure can lead to secretive, risky behaviour that feels safer in the short term but creates harm later.

Power dynamics and ethical questions around married partners

There’s an obvious ethical wrinkle when one of the partners is married. Reports summarising Underwood’s comments underline the imbalance: married partners may fear losing family, reputation or career, which can make them reluctant to speak up. That dynamic raises two tough realities , first, that secrecy can shield people from consequence; second, that it can also entrap them. Coverage from various outlets suggests the revelation has prompted wider conversation about accountability, especially when closeting intersects with relationships where other people’s lives are at stake.

Context from the coming-out journey and aftermath

Underwood publicly came out in 2021 and later chronicled his transition in a Netflix series that explored vulnerability and reconnecting with the LGBTQ+ community. Since then he’s married and become a parent, and he’s used interviews to reflect on mistakes and fear. Commentators have pointed out that coming out publicly doesn’t erase what happened before, but it does allow for reflection and, ideally, learning. For people watching, the takeaway is practical: secrecy made him make choices he now regrets, and honest support networks might reduce the need for that kind of self-protection.

How to think about this as a viewer, friend or fan

If you’re following the story, try to hold two truths at once: the harm of secretive choices and the human fear that drove them. For friends of someone struggling with identity, the lesson is simple and practical , create safe spaces, normalise support, and avoid shaming secrecy into harm. For audiences, it’s worth asking tougher questions about responsibility and consent when one partner is married, while also recognising the complexities of growing up with strict beliefs about sexuality.

It’s a small, sharp story about what secrecy can do , and a reminder that better conversations and safer supports matter.

Source Reference Map

Story idea inspired by: [1]

Sources by paragraph: