Queer films with explicit sex scenes can face a difficult choice: cut material to pursue an R rating, or keep the filmmakers’ intended version and accept NC-17 or an unrated release. That classification can make mainstream theatrical reach harder, but films including Passages show why some directors and distributors choose not to trim the story.
NC-17 can make a film harder to see
An NC-17 rating can complicate a film’s path to a wide audience. The classification has a reputation as a commercial obstacle, and filmmakers may be asked to cut scenes to seek an R rating. Some instead hold on to the version they want viewers to see, even if that means accepting NC-17 or releasing the film unrated.
That choice is about more than a rating label. The Motion Picture Association’s database records individual classifications and reasons, while Time describes the broader market concerns around NC-17 films. Neither source, on its own, establishes that LGBTQ+ films receive the rating more often than other films; that comparative claim would need broader evidence.
Passages puts the choice in plain view
Ira Sachs’s Passages centres on Tomas, a filmmaker played by Franz Rogowski, his long-term partner Martin, played by Ben Whishaw, and Agathe, a schoolteacher played by Adèle Exarchopoulos. When Tomas begins a relationship with Agathe, the already complicated bond between the three shifts again.
The Los Angeles Times reported that the Motion Picture Association gave Passages an NC-17 rating, but the film’s partners chose to release it unrated. Sachs said the production hadn’t considered cutting the film to obtain an R rating. It’s a clear example of the trade-off: preserve the film’s frank treatment of sex, and accept a less conventional route to audiences.
Four films, four different kinds of desire
The examples span decades and styles. Pedro Almodóvar’s Law of Desire, released in 1987, follows a love triangle involving director Pablo and Antonio Banderas’s character; Bad Education, released in 2004, centres on a filmmaker confronted by a former lover and a screenplay about their shared past. The Motion Picture Association’s records provide a way to check the films’ NC-17 classifications, while Rotten Tomatoes confirms Law of Desire’s year, director and cast.
Then there’s Blue Is the Warmest Color, the 2013 romance between Adèle and Emma, played by Adèle Exarchopoulos and Léa Seydoux. Its extended sex scenes have prompted debate, and the Motion Picture Association records its NC-17 rating for explicit sexual content. Apple TV’s listing confirms the central relationship and leading performers; it also notes the film’s Palme d’Or win.
The rating tells only part of the story
A classification can explain why a film might face distribution choices, but it doesn’t settle whether a scene is necessary, artful or excessive. In Blue Is the Warmest Color, for example, viewers have disagreed about how the sex scenes were filmed and what perspective they serve. That debate belongs to the film’s reception, not to the rating record itself.
For anyone choosing what to watch, it helps to separate three questions: what the film is about, why it received its rating, and how critics or audiences have responded to its sexual imagery. Official ratings pages are useful for the second; catalogue listings can confirm basic details, while reviews offer perspectives rather than a final verdict.
Keeping the cut can be a statement
The history of NC-17 helps explain why the decision carries weight. Time traces the classification to 1990, after the older X rating became difficult to market, and describes the commercial concerns that still surround NC-17 releases. Some films are released unrated instead, but that route comes with its own distribution considerations.
For Passages, the Los Angeles Times reported that the unrated release was a collective decision intended to let more people see the film in its original form. That tension is the heart of the issue: a rating may narrow a film’s options, while cutting scenes can change the work its creators set out to make. Sometimes, preserving the messy, intimate version is the point.
It’s worth looking beyond the rating and asking what the film is trying to show.
Source Reference Map
Story idea inspired by: [1]
Sources by paragraph: