A map of gay-related searches across US states has turned up some striking differences, from Utah’s interest in “Mormon” to Wisconsin’s in “circle jerk”. The figures make for an amusing snapshot, but they measure relative popularity on a platform, not how many people searched or what anyone’s identity is.

The map is funny, but the fine print matters

Some state search patterns are the sort that make you pause over a map. Utah stands out for “Mormon” searches, while Wisconsin is associated with “circle jerk” and Massachusetts with “tickle”. The results are unexpected enough to invite a laugh, but they need a little context.

Instinct Magazine’s map, attributed to Stats by Sunil, compares how popular particular searches are in each state relative to the rest of the country. It doesn’t give the number of people who searched, specify the period covered or explain how the data was collected. So it’s best read as an entertaining snapshot, not a portrait of what residents are like.

A few state results really stand out

The headline figures are eye-catching: Utah’s “Mormon” searches were reported as 845 per cent higher than elsewhere, Wisconsin’s “circle jerk” at 762 per cent, and Massachusetts’s “tickle” at 718 per cent. Other striking entries include Ohio for “cum in mouth”, Wyoming for “sucking” and South Dakota for “furry”.

There are more varied regional examples, too. New York and New Jersey both feature “Dominican”, California has “Asian”, and Nevada has “Latino”. Elsewhere, New Hampshire is linked to “gay” and Alaska to “twink”. These labels point to search patterns in the map, not to the number or identities of people in any state.

Other reports offer useful context

The map’s broad picture fits with earlier media coverage of platform data. BuzzFeed, PinkNews and Indy100 have all discussed state-by-state patterns in adult-content searches or viewing, including Utah’s “Mormon”, Wisconsin’s “circle jerk” and South Dakota’s “furry”.

But the figures aren’t all measuring the same thing. Indy100 distinguishes between estimates of viewing time and searches or categories that are relatively popular, while PinkNews notes that state comparisons use a national baseline rather than raw search totals. A map can make those differences easy to miss.

Platform data isn’t a census

Pornhub’s 2017 Year in Review describes search and viewing trends among visitors to its gay pages, while IFLScience has covered maps built from Pornhub Insights data. Both provide a reminder that platform analytics describe activity on that platform, not every online search in the US.

And a search label doesn’t establish a visitor’s sexuality, gender or motivation. PinkNews and Indy100 both note that people viewing gay male content aren’t necessarily gay men. That’s a useful distinction whenever a colourful map starts to look like a definitive guide to a whole population.

Enjoy the oddities, keep the caveats

There’s plenty to enjoy in the variety, from Montana’s “cowboy” searches to West Virginia’s “redneck” and Iowa’s “tickle”. The results are amusing partly because they resist a neat explanation; without the underlying methodology, there’s no sound basis for guessing why one term ranks higher in one place than another.

The practical takeaway is simple: check what a chart is comparing before reading too much into its labels. Relative popularity, total searches and viewing time are different measures, and none alone tells the full story.

Treat the map as a curious snapshot, not a state-by-state verdict.

Source Reference Map

Story idea inspired by: [1]

Sources by paragraph: