Netflix’s The Body puts Anya and Elise’s attraction at the heart of a Catholic-school thriller, asking what happens when one girl sees their intimacy as real and the other calls it experimentation. Set against a Y2K backdrop of dance-team rituals and religious imagery, the series offers a more emotionally complicated picture of sapphic desire than the familiar male-centred trope.

Essential Takeaways

  • A complicated central relationship: Anya and Elise’s attraction is shaped by friendship, uncertainty and unequal expectations.
  • More than a flirtation: The series explores the emotional consequences of Anya’s attempts to frame intimacy as experimentation.
  • A Catholic-school setting: The story brings teenage sexuality and faith together in a heightened psychological drama.
  • A personal creative lens: Creator Quinn Shephard has discussed the show’s interest in femininity, girlhood and queer experience.

The Body gives sapphic desire emotional stakes

The tension between Anya and Elise isn’t simply whether they’re attracted to each other. It’s whether they understand their intimacy in the same way. DIVA’s account of the series focuses on the painful gap between Anya’s insistence that they’re “just messing around” and Elise’s apparent longing for something more.

That distinction gives the relationship its weight. The Guardian also describes Anya’s denial and Elise’s distress at rejection as central emotional tensions, while TheWrap points to the damage caused by Anya’s dishonesty and difficulty recognising the effect of her choices. The drama makes room for desire, but it also asks viewers to notice what happens when one person’s version of an encounter leaves the other feeling unseen.

A Catholic school turns private feelings into public pressure

The Body follows a group of students at a Catholic school, with Anya and Elise connected through the Lions dance team. Marie Claire’s cast guide identifies Anya as the team’s popular captain and Elise as her close friend and fellow Lion, placing their relationship inside a wider social world of friendships, faith and status.

That setting brings extra pressure to questions of sexuality and belonging. The Guardian describes the show as a retro, camp coming-of-age drama set in 2004, blending high-school themes with religious symbolism, supernatural incidents and dark humour. It’s a busy mix, but the contrast between the polished dance-team world and the characters’ unsettled private lives helps frame the story’s conflicts.

Y2K style is more than a nostalgic backdrop

The early-2000s atmosphere gives the series a distinctive visual language, but Shephard’s creative references reach beyond nostalgia. In an interview with Marie Claire, she discusses the influence of religious art, dance-team imagery and films such as Carrie, alongside themes of religion, shame, group behaviour and coming of age.

Dance, in particular, can suggest conformity as well as shared identity, according to Shephard’s comments to Marie Claire. That’s a useful lens for watching a story built around a close-knit team: fitting in may look effortless from the outside, while private questions of faith, desire and self-understanding remain unresolved.

Why the male-gaze trope matters here

The familiar “my boyfriend will think it’s hot” framing treats intimacy between women as something performed for male approval. DIVA argues that The Body pushes against that idea by giving Anya and Elise’s relationship emotional consequences rather than presenting it only as spectacle. The Guardian’s review likewise places their attraction and Elise’s hurt near the centre of the drama.

The distinction isn’t that characters must always know exactly what they want. Anya’s uncertainty is part of the story. But when she tries to bring her boyfriend into the picture through a proposed threesome, DIVA describes Elise as visibly uncomfortable and walking away. The moment underlines a simple point: one person’s idea of experimentation can be another’s experience of rejection.

The performances and creative intent add context

Kristina Bogic plays Anya and Sara Boustany plays Elise, according to Netflix’s official Media Centre. The actors have also spoken with Interview Magazine about making a series that brings together teenage sexuality, religion, supernatural elements and secrets, offering a behind-the-scenes view of the show’s unusual blend of genres.

Shephard has linked the project to her own process of understanding queer identity and femininity in interviews cited by DIVA and Marie Claire. That background helps explain why the series is interested not just in attraction, but in the rules girls are expected to follow. There are no confirmed plans for a second season in the lead report, but the show’s central question already has plenty to sit with: who gets to decide what an intimate moment means?

The Body is at its most compelling when attraction feels messy, personal and impossible to reduce to a performance.

Source Reference Map

Story idea inspired by: [1]

Sources by paragraph: