A quiet project by Rabbi Moshe Hauer has left a question hanging over the Orthodox Union: what might a guide to LGBTQ+ inclusion have said, and could it have changed anything? The unfinished framework came to light after his death, just as advocates say hard-won progress in some Orthodox communities is facing a setback.

Essential takeaways

  • An unpublished project: Hauer was working on a framework for LGBTQ+ inclusion in Orthodox communities, but its scope and status remain unknown.
  • A careful acknowledgement: The only published excerpt recognises the challenges faced by Orthodox Jews with same-sex attraction or gender dysphoria.
  • Religious doctrine remains central: The OU has said its understanding of Jewish law defines marriage as between a man and a woman.
  • Other institutions have issued policies: The Rabbinical Council of America adopted a resolution in 2016, while Yeshiva University ended a student group it said was functioning as a Pride club.
  • Local support varies: Eshel’s Welcoming Shuls Project helps LGBTQ+ people and Orthodox communities navigate questions of inclusion, with approaches shaped by each community.

A lost guide, and a question with no easy answer

A single sentence is all the public has seen from Rabbi Moshe Hauer’s unfinished work on LGBTQ+ inclusion. It acknowledges the “unimaginable challenges” faced by Orthodox Jews with same-sex attraction or gender dysphoria as they navigate Jewish law and their place in the community. The words are measured, but their appearance has revived a bigger debate about whether a major Orthodox institution can offer meaningful recognition without changing its religious commitments.

The Forward reported that the project emerged in a tribute published by the OU’s magazine, Jewish Action, around the first anniversary of Hauer’s death in October 2025. The Orthodox Union described the work as unfinished scholarship, and the document’s length, intended audience and final shape remain unclear. For now, the missing pages matter as much as the published line: no one outside the project can say what else it might have proposed.

The OU’s stance on marriage sets the backdrop

Hauer’s project sat within a long-running tension between Orthodox law and the desire to make communal life less isolating for LGBTQ+ people. The Orthodox Union has said that its religious understanding defines marriage as a relationship between a man and a woman. At the same time, its 2022 statement on the Respect for Marriage Act distinguished that religious position from civil law and supported protections for religious liberty.

That distinction helps explain why an inclusion framework could have been significant without necessarily changing the OU’s position on same-sex relationships. But it also points to the limits any such guidance might have faced. As The Forward noted, supporters and critics alike questioned whether an OU document could satisfy communities with sharply different expectations.

Other Orthodox institutions have drawn their own lines

The OU isn’t the only major Orthodox body to wrestle with the issue. In 2016, the Rabbinical Council of America adopted a resolution calling for support for people with same-sex attraction while saying rabbis and Orthodox institutions should not publicly sanction relationships prohibited by Jewish law. Its resolution also recognised the strain of the restrictions it described, making empathy part of its pastoral approach.

Yeshiva University’s May 2025 memorandum took a different form, addressing a student group called Hareni. The university’s religious leaders said the group’s activities amounted to a Pride club under another name and were inconsistent with the school’s Torah values and the group’s approved terms; they directed student-life staff to discontinue it. These are institution-specific positions, not a single rulebook for Orthodox life, but together they show how contested LGBTQ+ inclusion remains.

Inclusion often starts close to home

For people seeking support, national statements are only part of the picture. Eshel’s Welcoming Shuls Project works with Orthodox communities on religious, communal and personal questions, and helps LGBTQ+ people and families find information about synagogue policies. It stresses that communities differ, so its work is shaped by local circumstances rather than one universal model.

That practical, local focus matters when people may want answers without revealing their identity publicly. Eshel also offers confidential liaison between individuals, relatives and community leaders. If you’re looking for a welcoming synagogue, its project advises contacting the organisation for current information, since public listings may not include sensitive details.

A public conversation could still count

The Forward’s reporting captures two competing possibilities. Some advocates doubt that guidance framed by Orthodox law could move attitudes much; others argue that even respectful language from an organisation as prominent as the OU could make a difference. The only published excerpt cannot settle that argument, and it shouldn’t be mistaken for the complete document.

Still, a conversation that was once largely out of view has entered the open. That may not resolve the difficult choices facing LGBTQ+ Orthodox Jews or their communities, but it gives people a starting point for asking what compassion, belonging and religious commitment can look like together.

The unfinished guide remains a mystery, but the question it raised is now harder to ignore.

Source Reference Map

Story idea inspired by: [1]

Sources by paragraph:

  • Paragraph 1: [2]
  • Paragraph 2: [2]
  • Paragraph 3: [3]
  • Paragraph 4: [2], [3]
  • Paragraph 5: [4]
  • Paragraph 6: [5]
  • Paragraph 7: [7]
  • Paragraph 8: [7]
  • Paragraph 9: [2]
  • Paragraph 10: [2]